Bad Luck Or Bad Baseball?

Is it bad luck or bad baseball?  It looked like luck may have been in the Phillies favor when Red Sox starter Daisuke Matsuzaka was sent to the DL minutes before the game started today.  Dice-K beat up the Phillies in their last meeting, so this must be good news.  Scott Atchison, a career minor leaguer who also played in Japan, made his first career major league start in place of Dice-K.  Again, this seemed like good news, right?

Wrong.  Because absolutely nothing has gone well for the Phillies lately, and this game would be no different.  Joe Blanton has been as bad as he could be since coming off the DL in early May.  By the 2nd inning of this game, Blanton had given up 34 runs, 11 homers and 11 walks in 45 innings pitched this year. 
Bad luck Phillies.jpg
And the damage did not end there…Blanton allowed 9 runs total, matching Jamie Moyer yesterday, on 13 hits and a walk by the time he was done, after 4 pathetic innings. His ERA is now 7.28.

Blanton loaded the bases in the 2nd inning, right after the offense scored two runs for him.  He then threw ONE pitch to rookie, Daniel Nava, who in his first major league at-bat, hit a grand slam!  Unbelievable.  It looked like the Phillies had morphed into a black cat with a #13 tattoo, under a black cloud standing on top of a broken mirror, sprinkled with spilled salt.  But was that bad luck or just Joe Blah-anton?

Blanton needs to go.  Obviously, no one will want him with his gigantic 7.28 ERA and gigantic salary, so what are the options?  Put him back on the DL or send him to the minors.  Brett Myers did this voluntarily back in 2008 and came back to help them win the World Series.  The Phillies can bring back Nelson Figueroa or someone else from the minors.  I would rather see a rookie get raked for 9 runs than a veteran who is not living up to his end of the deal.  How about Nate Bump?  He has some experience and was recently clocked at 103mph.  Go get him!

The Phillies have made a lot of mistakes this year and last, many of which have been overshadowed by the acquisition of Roy Halladay.  Letting Myers go was clearly an error in judgment.  I said it before, but because most people have a personal dislike of Myers, most were happy to see him go.  For the Astros this year, Myers has not allowed more than 4 runs in any game, has not pitched fewer than 6 innings in any game and his ERA is a very respectable 3.18.

And do not even get me started on Cliff Lee.  Because the Mariners are not doing well, Lee will likely be traded before the deadline and it looks like he may wind up in the NL East.  Imagine this: Lee goes to Mets or the Braves who make the playoffs, leaving the Phillies in the dust.  You want to throw up right now, don’t you?

And remember signing a 36 year-old Raul Ibanez, now 38, to a 3-year contract?  It looked like a good idea for ½ a year in 2009; now, not so much.  Raul, we still love ya, but things are not going well.  Ibanez is hitting .247 and is getting slower in the outfield.

The Phillies also extended Blanton’s contract this off-season, giving him 3 more years and $24 million dollars.  They noted his “consistency,” which I have never agreed with, and his ability to pitch many innings as reasons for the extension.  Well, all those innings have taken their toll as evidenced by Blanton’s current ERA plus the pre-season injury and DL stint.

By the way, the Phillies offense died after Blanton dug a huge hole for them.  The managed only 7 hits and 3 of those came from back-up catcher Brian Schneider.  The Phillies went on to lose the game by a score of 2-10.

panic.jpgI could go on, but I think that is enough for one day.  The Phillies have now slid from 1st place to 3rd place in the NL East and if the Marlins keep winning, they will be in 4th place shortly.  I mentioned holding off on hitting the panic button last week; well, it is now time.  Let the panic begin.  This past month may be a foretelling of the horror to come.


Photoshopping by Jenn

*Read more about the Phillies at my other home page, Phightin’ Phils Phorum in the My Team Rivals network*




  1. barbward

    I agree with you on most of your points. You were able to say much that my blog entry couldn’t. I just couldn’t find the words today.The team, however, keeps saying that it isn’t time to hit the panic button. They even had a team meeting before yesterdays’s game. I think that they’re trying to stay positive which isn’t a bad thing. When the game started, they looked determined. Things were in their favor with the last minute change of pitchers. Blanton was reported to have worked on his pitching. All was for naught though. They just keep on getting beaten up and , sad to say, they’re allowing it to happen. I’m hangin in there because that’s what true fans do. It’s not easy though.

  2. muleman

    I’m not as sure that the Mariners will look to trade Lee. They’re disappointing, yes, but they also think they can win, and I don’t see them abandoning ship so early into the process.

    The thing that kills me about this team is the bench. They’re historically weak against AL teams, and I think part of the reason is that they have no DH when they go to AL ballparks. Dobbs (.138) and Gload (.213) aren’t much better than sending a pitcher up to hit. In fact, Hamels is hitting .167. Maybe he should DH today? 🙂

    Of course, the peril of sliding to 4th place is having 3 teams to jump over to get to first. It’s a bad way to start the second half, and with games against the Yankees and Twins looming, the future is kind of bleak.

  3. Jane Heller

    I understand your impulse to throw up, Jenn! You guys have had a bad streak and yesterday must have been a total bummer – especially because you thought you had luck on your side going into the game. Maybe the Phillies can get Lee back?

  4. leec

    How quickly Phillies fans seem to forget. Blanton has been horrible the first half of the season for years. For whatever reason he doesn’t find his stride until July. He was something like 5-12 when the Phils traded for him at Oakland. Last year he was amazingly hittable the first half of the season. So give up on him and trade him as quickly as you can and we Braves fans will be happy to see him gone when he hits his stride for someone else down the stretch.

  5. redheadfilly

    This has been the most depressing 3-4 weeks watching these games. What has happened? Where are my boys? It is so painful because we rightfully expect more and they are not playing up to their potential. It is an embarrassment that we fans do not deserve to witness. Does anyone have the number to the suicide prevention hotline? I may need it handy if this continues. LOL

  6. phillies_phollowers

    Barb – we are all trying to hang too…it is going to be a rough summer.
    Muleman- I know, the bench is just one more thing that is killing us. I like the idea of Hamels as the DH…lol
    Jane – this may all be good news for the Yanks, but I hope they at least put up a fight, ya know? And I think most would give their non-pitching arm to have Lee back ;o)
    Leec – Blanton is a slow starter, but has never been THIS bad. I could deal with slow, but his season has been a total disaster. He needs to go down and work out his issues or go home. I think the early season injury is affecting him.
    Redhead – If you find a #, please pass it on! LOL
    Jeff – METS is a 4-letter word. ;o)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s